Thursday, November 15, 2012

After Reading "How Much Land Does a Man Need?"


Day 1- Essay Planning

Essay Assignment- Write a four to five paragraph essay on the human lesson and historical connection in Tolstoy’s “How Much Land Does a Man Need?”
Required tools to complete this task:
1.       Paragraph written about “Literature in Context” (p350) and “Meeting Leo Tolstoy” (p337)
2.       Thorough understanding of the short story itself
3.       Understanding of the vocabulary’s connection to the story’s theme
4.       Research of a reliable source from the internet

In class activity:  take an inventory of the tools that you possess from above, create an organized outline and write an introduction for the essay.

Homework- Research and find a reliable source from the internet that connects to the short story’s assignment; write the information into a paragraph and document your source.

YOU MAY USE THE CENGAGE LIBRARY THROUGH THE SCHOOL'S WEBSITE


Day 2- Essay Planning

Task- write a four to five paragraph (approximately five complete sentences in each paragraph) essay on the theme of Leo Tolstoy’s “How Much Land Does a Man Need?” that incorporates biographical and historical information,  with support from a research source.  Your essay should communicate your ideas clearly through the use of vocabulary from the unit and English language conventions. 
Use your prior knowledge of source documentation, formalist analysis and writing process.  Here are four key elements that should be included in your essay.  The Rubric below graphs your evaluation on the assignment as a whole.  Each step of this process will be graded as well.

1.       Research as support for theme or social studies information
2.       Inclusion of historical and biographical information
3.       Expression of theme and support from deep reading
4.       Use of vocabulary from the lesson and English language conventions


RUBRIC
Criteria:
1-9pts
10-14pts
15-19pts
20-25pts
Theme and Support- formalist argument
Point is unclear or vague with minimal development.  Lack of a thorough and interesting discussion of the texts meaning and/ or value
Expression of the overall point of the short story with references to the text to support your reading of the meaning
Thorough statement on the value and meaning of the text through the use of a literary element that supports your formalist reading
Complex and thorough statement about the meaning and value of the text with support from the text, using literary elements such as symbolism, characterization and plot analysis
Cross Curriculum Connect
Mentioning of the historical or biographical information that doesn’t clearly connect to your analysis of the story
Use of either the historical or the biographical information that connects to your analysis of the story
Incorporation of historical and biographical information into the essay that adequately discusses the connection between the literary and the historical
Incorporation of the historical and biographical information that adds  interesting dimensions to the meaning of the text and the value of literary texts to understanding historical moments
Research Support
Minimal discussion of a research source with little connection to any of the points in your essay with not citation in the text or work cited information
Mentioning of your source in order to discuss and support one of your points, without citation or work cited information.
Useful selection of a reliable source that discusses your point about the short story or the biographical/ historical information you have discussed.  Use of a technically correct work citation of your source.
Careful selection of a reliable source that reinforces your formalist reading of the text and the historical/ biographical  connection you have made.  Use of in text citation and a work citation, accurately and technically correct
Organization, Vocabulary and Language Conventions
No use of the vocabulary in an appropriate and correct manner throughout the essay.  Essay organization lacks proper paragraphing.  Language and sentence structure is an obstacle to understanding the writer’s point
All paragraphs are not used adequately to express each aspect of the whole essay, but some paragraphs are present that express the points of the essay.  Paragraphs may be too long or too short or even missing.  Language is clear enough to understand the point of the writer.  Less than five words from the unit are used to greater and lesser degrees of accuracy
Adequately planned and organized into clear points through paragraphing, appropriate sentence structure and word choice.  Five words from the unit are used but not all are accurately and correctly placed into their respective sentences.
The essay is organized in a thoughtful and artful manner that clearly discusses each aspect flowing smoothly with use of not only appropriate sentence structure but at least five of the vocabulary words studied in this unit.